Guides / Classification systems

Same names, different systems: body shape classification for a body type calculator

Apple, pear, hourglass, rectangle and inverted triangle are familiar styling words, but no single international or Chinese standard we reviewed defines all five with one set of inputs and thresholds. Apparel standards describe measurements or garment sizes; FFIT and BSAS are research systems with different inputs and purposes; consumer guides use their own formulas or visual judgments. The same label can mean different things.

Editorial status: internal source and method review completed on 17 November 2026. This is an internal review, not external professional review or certification. Sources are cited at the level each one can support; see the limitations below.

Key findings

Five things to know before comparing body shape systems

  1. The five consumer labels are editorial categories, not one standardized taxonomy.

    In the sources reviewed, no single international or Chinese standard defines all five consumer labels with one input set and threshold. Consumer guides use different names, inputs and rules; some allow visual judgment or interchangeable shoulder and bust inputs.

    The Concept WardrobeWho What Wear UKSewing.org

  2. FFIT is a research classification with nine shapes and six girth inputs.

    FFIT for Apparel sorts 3D body scans into nine shapes using bust, waist, hips, high hip, abdomen and stomach. It is not the five consumer labels, and Bodytype does not claim to implement FFIT.

    FFIT Part II (full text)FFIT Part I

  3. BSAS is an expert-assessment instrument, not a four-girth formula.

    The Body Shape Assessment Scale rates body scans on nine scales: three whole-body (Body Build, Body Shape, Posture) and six component parts. It captures posture and local shape that a four-girth calculator cannot.

    BSAS (abstract)

  4. Apparel sizing standards define measurements or size codes, not styling labels.

    GB/T 1335.2 uses Y/A/B/C garment size codes based on the bust-waist difference. ISO 8559-1 and GB/T 16160 define how to measure. None of them defines apple, pear or hourglass.

    GB/T 1335.2 recordISO 8559-1GB/T 16160 record

  5. Bodytype's five labels are its own styling rules.

    Bodytype v2 uses four girths, publishes its three ratios and fixed thresholds, and separates measurement definitions from classification labels. The thresholds are styling rules, not a standard or a health measure.

    Bodytype rule orderThe five labels

01 / The core idea

Why the same label can mean different things

Consumer body-shape labels are an editorial framework, not a measurement protocol. The same word can be produced from girth ratios, a visual silhouette, a shoulder-or-bust substitution, or a fixed difference in inches. Two pages can both say “hourglass” and mean different constructions.

Before comparing two results, ask what inputs a source used, what thresholds it applied, and what it is for. The point is not that every guide is unreliable. The point is that results are not directly comparable unless the definitions match.

In the sources reviewed, no single standard defined all five consumer labels with one input set and threshold.

This is a statement about the sources checked for this guide, not a claim that no standard could ever exist. Standards define measurements or garment sizes; research systems define their own categories; Bodytype publishes a separate four-girth styling rule set.

02 / Consumer labels

Useful, but not one taxonomy

The common five labels are hourglass, pear or triangle, inverted triangle, apple or oval, and rectangle. But the names, the count and the inputs vary by source. The Concept Wardrobe uses five labels and measures shoulders, bust, waist and hips; Who What Wear limits itself to four and omits apple; Sewing.org uses five with two kinds of rectangle and no apple; a Kentucky extension guide groups apple with reverse triangle.

Triangle / Pear

The same lower-body-prominent idea under two names; some guides add a shoulder input.

Apple / Oval

A midsection-prominent idea; Who What Wear omits it, The Concept Wardrobe keeps it.

Rectangle / Straight / Ruler / Banana

A straight silhouette; Sewing.org splits it into Slim and Wide Rectangle, Vogue China calls it banana.

Inverted triangle / V shape / Reverse triangle

An upper-body-prominent idea; the Kentucky guide groups it with apple.

The thresholds are editorial too. The Concept Wardrobe and Who What Wear both use a 5% bust-to-hip balance and a waist at least 25% smaller than the bust or hips for hourglass. Those numbers belong to those pages, not to an industry standard. The Kentucky guide instead calls a body straight when bust, waist and hips are equal or within one inch. Some guides allow a visual mirror judgment or let you swap shoulder and bust inputs, which can place the same body in two categories.

Consumer labels are good for browsing and communication. They are not a cross-site measurement classification. The Concept Wardrobe itself calls the theory a rough guide and somewhat outdated.

03 / The core asset

The systems matrix

Nine systems, side by side. Each card states what the system is for, what it takes as input, what it outputs, how it works, what evidence supports it, and — just as important — what it cannot support. No system is ranked above another; they answer different questions.

Editorial categories

Consumer styling labels

Purpose
Quick communication and content browsing.
Inputs
Girths, visual silhouette, shoulder or bust; varies by source.
Outputs
Commonly four to five labels; names and counts differ by source.
Method
Editorial rules, ratios, fixed differences or visual judgment.
Evidence
Each source's own description; no shared validation.
Can support
Everyday vocabulary and a content entry point.
Cannot support
A cross-site unified classification or algorithm certification.

Reviewed 17 Nov 2026: S4 uses five labels, S5 four, S17 five with two rectangles.

The Concept WardrobeWho What Wear UKSewing.org

This site's styling rule set

Bodytype v2

Purpose
A four-girth styling reference.
Inputs
Bust, waist, high hip and hips girths (ASTM D5219-25 3.3–3.5).
Outputs
Hourglass, Pear, Inverted triangle, Apple, Rectangle.
Method
Three ratios plus fixed thresholds in a fixed rule order.
Evidence
Published site rules and tests; not a population validation.
Can support
A reproducible site classification and boundary prompts.
Cannot support
Medical or health judgment, or FFIT/BSAS certification.

Verified against rules.ts and thresholds.ts source, 17 Nov 2026.

Bodytype methodBoundary sensitivity

Research classification

FFIT for Apparel

Purpose
Shape grouping for apparel research and mass customization.
Inputs
Six girths from 3D scans: bust, waist, hips, high hip, abdomen, stomach.
Outputs
Nine shapes: hourglass, bottom hourglass, top hourglass, spoon, triangle, inverted triangle, rectangle, diamond, oval.
Method
Software rules combining differences and ratios of the six girths.
Evidence
2004 refereed papers; 887-subject validation; 2021 reliability study.
Can support
A research taxonomy and evidence that measurement placement matters.
Cannot support
A synonym for the five consumer labels, or site algorithm certification.

Full text reviewed 17 Nov 2026 (Part II); six girths come from 3D scans.

FFIT Part II2021 reliability study

Expert-assessment instrument

BSAS

Purpose
Whole-body shape and component-part assessment.
Inputs
Expert observation of body scans, front and side views.
Outputs
Nine scales: three whole-body (Body Build, Body Shape, Posture) and six component parts.
Method
Expert rating scale, later programmed into software.
Evidence
2006 peer-reviewed instrument development; 42 scans to build, 100 to validate.
Can support
Showing that body shape is a multi-dimensional assessment.
Cannot support
A four-girth self-test formula, or site algorithm certification.

Abstract reviewed 17 Nov 2026; full scale text not retrieved (see limitations).

BSAS (abstract)

Chinese garment sizing standard

GB/T 1335.2-2008

Purpose
Garment size designation and selection for women.
Inputs
Height (号) and bust or waist girth (型), plus the bust-waist difference.
Outputs
Y/A/B/C garment body-type codes.
Method
Size series; codes keyed to the bust-waist difference.
Evidence
National standard; official record confirms current status.
Can support
Garment size codes and a selection framework.
Cannot support
Apple/pear styling labels, or any judgment of figure quality.

Official record + mirror clause 3.3 reviewed 17 Nov 2026.

Official recordStandard text mirror

International measurement standard

ISO 8559-1:2017

Purpose
Anthropometric definitions for body measurement.
Inputs
Measurement items and landmarks.
Outputs
Terms and definitions; no styling categories.
Method
Standard definitions and measurement principles.
Evidence
ISO official scope page; confirmed current in 2026.
Can support
Checking what to measure and how to measure it.
Cannot support
The five labels, or Bodytype thresholds.

Official scope page reviewed 17 Nov 2026; clauses not itemized.

ISO 8559-1

Chinese measurement standard

GB/T 16160-2017

Purpose
Dimension definitions and methods for garment anthropometry.
Inputs
Measurement items.
Outputs
Terms and methods; no styling categories.
Method
Standard definitions.
Evidence
Official record; current, 2025 review concluded revision.
Can support
Checking measurement methods.
Cannot support
The five labels, or Bodytype thresholds.

Official record reviewed 17 Nov 2026; revision plan being approved.

Official record

Style and image system

Kibbe / Image Identity

Purpose
A holistic style image, not a proportion calculator.
Inputs
Overall appearance, bone structure, flesh and facial features.
Outputs
13 archetypes in five type families.
Method
Yin/yang balance and style analysis.
Evidence
Consumer/style guides; David Kibbe, Metamorphosis (1987).
Can support
Style content and a whole-image approach.
Cannot support
Four-girth proportion classification, or medical use.

Reviewed 17 Nov 2026; source calls these archetypes, not body types.

Kibbe introduction

Health-risk research

WHO waist / waist-hip ratio

Purpose
Predicting disease risk at population level.
Inputs
Waist circumference, hip circumference and related measures.
Outputs
Risk stratification and research cut-off points.
Method
Epidemiology and expert consultation.
Evidence
WHO expert consultation (2008), published 2011.
Can support
Health-risk research context.
Cannot support
Styling classification, or endorsement of the five labels.

Reviewed 17 Nov 2026; not used in the Bodytype algorithm.

WHO report
Download the systems matrix (CSV)

The CSV carries the same fields and source IDs as these cards. It does not bundle external standard text or long excerpts.

04 / Research system

FFIT for Apparel

The Female Figure Identification Technique was developed at North Carolina State University and described in two refereed 2004 papers in the Journal of Textile and Apparel, Technology and Management: Part I (Simmons, Istook and Devarajan) lays out the shape-sorting framework, and Part II (Devarajan and Istook) validates the software. It sorts 3D body scans, not manual tape readings.

FFIT uses six girths taken from the scan data and combines their differences and ratios in a fixed order to assign one of nine shapes.

BustWaistHipsHigh hipAbdomenStomach
HourglassBottom hourglassTop hourglassSpoonTriangleInverted triangleRectangleDiamondOval

The software was built from a convenience sample of 253 women and validated on 887 subjects, with a reported software accuracy of around 90% against a discriminant function. Those are study-specific numbers, not a claim about all calculators or about Bodytype.

Measurement placement matters: up to 40% in one study.

Parker and colleagues (2021) analysed 1,679 3D body scans and found that different interpretations of FFIT's measurement placement — FFIT's own guidance versus SizeUK's — categorised the same body into different shapes in up to 40% of cases. They also note FFIT omits shoulder measurements. This is evidence about definition sensitivity in a specific sample, not an error rate for every calculator.

Bodytype does not claim to implement FFIT. Four girths cannot reproduce a six-girth, nine-shape system, and a shared name like hourglass does not mean the same category. See Part II and the 2021 study.

05 / Research instrument

BSAS: shape as a multi-dimensional assessment

The Body Shape Assessment Scale (Connell and colleagues, 2006, Clothing and Textiles Research Journal) uses expert knowledge to rate female body shapes as visualized in body scans. It was developed from 42 scans of women aged 20–55 and validated by five experts rating 100 additional scans, then programmed into software.

BSAS has nine scales read from front and side views: three for the whole body — Body Build, Body Shape and Posture — and six for component parts: Front Torso Shape, Hip Shape, Shoulder Slope, Bust Shape, Buttocks Shape and Back Curvature. It is an expert-assessment instrument, not a four-girth formula you can port into a web calculator.

Verification level: the nine-scale structure, samples and expert method are taken from the published abstract. The abstract does not enumerate the Body Shape scale's categories. The related Auburn work (Connell, 2002), described in FFIT Part II, uses hourglass, rectangle, pear and inverted triangle — apple is not among those four. This guide does not claim to have read the full BSAS scale text. See BSAS and FFIT Part II.

06 / Standards

Apparel sizing and measurement standards

Three standards are often mistaken for body-shape classification. They are not. They define sizes or measurements, not styling labels.

GB/T 1335.2-2008 — garment size codes

This Chinese standard, Standard sizing systems for garments - Women, is current (published 2008-12-31, implemented 2009-08-01). It uses 号 (height) and 型 (bust or waist girth), and divides body type into four codes by the bust-waist difference. Clause 3.3 of the standard text gives: Y 19–24 cm, A 14–18 cm, B 9–13 cm, C 4–8 cm. These are garment size codes, not apple/pear/hourglass labels, and they say nothing about figure quality.

Y 19–24 cmA 14–18 cmB 9–13 cmC 4–8 cm

The ranges are read from a mirror of the standard text and cross-checked against the official record for number, title, status and dates. Formal citation should use the official text. See the record and the mirror.

ISO 8559-1:2017 — measurement definitions

ISO 8559-1 provides anthropometric definitions for body measurement, a basis for physical and digital anthropometric databases and for size and shape profiles. It was confirmed current in 2026. It tells you what to measure and how; it does not define the five consumer labels. This guide verified the official scope, not every clause.

GB/T 16160-2017 — measurement methods

GB/T 16160 defines dimensions and methods for garment anthropometry. The official record shows it is current, implemented 2018-07-01, with a 2025 review concluding revision and a revision plan being approved. Like ISO 8559-1, it is a measurement standard, not a body-shape classification.

A national standard does not classify you as a pear. It defines a size code or a measurement method.

07 / Cross-reference

Same name, different meaning

The same label across four systems. Read across a row to see why a shared word is not a shared definition. The BSAS column reflects the related Auburn four-shape work described in FFIT Part II, not a verified reading of the full BSAS scale text.

LabelConsumer contentFFITBSASBodytype v2Why not equal
HourglassBust or shoulders balanced with hips, a clearly defined waist.One of nine shapes, by six-girth rules.A whole-body Body Shape rating, by expert assessment.Bust-to-hip 0.95–1.05, waist-to-hip ≤ 0.80, high-hip-to-hip ≤ 0.95.Inputs, thresholds and assessment method all differ.
Pear / TriangleHips or lower body prominent relative to the upper body.Triangle is one of nine shapes.Pear appears in the related Auburn four-shape work.Bust-to-hip < 0.95.Consumer guides may use shoulder width; Bodytype has no shoulder input.
Inverted triangleShoulders or upper body prominent relative to the lower body.One of nine shapes.Appears in the related Auburn four-shape work.Bust-to-hip > 1.05.Bodytype measures bust only; it cannot infer shoulder width.
RectangleUpper, middle and lower body close; little waist definition.One of nine shapes.Appears in the related Auburn four-shape work.Balanced bust-hip with waist-to-hip between 0.80 and 0.88, or a defined waist but high-hip-to-hip > 0.95.What counts as 'close' uses different thresholds.
Apple / OvalWaist, abdomen or upper midsection prominent.Oval (and the related Diamond) among nine shapes.Not listed among the four shapes in the related Auburn work.Balanced bust-hip with waist-to-hip ≥ 0.88.Consumer guides may use the largest waist; Bodytype uses a ratio rule.
SpoonRarely used in consumer content.One of nine shapes.Not listed among the four shapes in the related Auburn work.No corresponding label.Belongs only in the FFIT context.
DiamondRarely used in consumer content.One of nine shapes.Not listed among the four shapes in the related Auburn work.No corresponding label.Belongs only in the FFIT context.

08 / Adjacent but different

Kibbe and WHO are not body-shape standards

Two neighbouring systems are often pulled into the same conversation. Neither is a four-girth styling classification.

Kibbe / Image Identity

David Kibbe's system, introduced in Metamorphosis (1987), describes 13 archetypes in five type families — Dramatic, Natural, Classic, Gamine and Romantic — based on a yin/yang balance across bone structure, flesh and facial features. It is a holistic style image. The source itself notes these are archetypes or image identity types, with very little to do with traditional apple/pear body types. They cannot be mapped one-to-one onto the five labels.

WHO waist circumference and waist-hip ratio

The WHO expert consultation (Geneva, 2008; published 2011) reviews waist circumference and waist-hip ratio as predictors of cardiovascular disease and diabetes risk, with cut-off points for public health action. This is a health-risk research context. It does not enter the Bodytype algorithm and does not endorse the five styling labels. Bodytype's waist-to-hip thresholds are styling rules, not WHO risk boundaries.

09 / This site

What Bodytype does — and does not do

Bodytype v2 takes four girths — bust, waist, high hip and hips — with tape positions following ASTM D5219-25 sections 3.3–3.5. It computes three ratios (bust-to-hip, waist-to-hip, high-hip-to-hip) and applies fixed thresholds in a fixed order to return one of five labels. The ratios, thresholds and order are published.

It does not use FFIT's six girths and nine shapes, BSAS's expert scales, GB/T size codes, Kibbe archetypes or WHO risk scores. It has no shoulder-width input, so inverted triangle means only that bust is large relative to hips — it cannot mean “shoulders wider than hips”. The thresholds are Bodytype's own styling rules, not a standard, and the result is not a medical or health judgment.

Open the body type calculatorRead the five labels

Related: waist and high hip definitions, the measurement guide, how close the thresholds are and the method and limits.

10 / Practical check

Questions to ask before comparing

  1. "I am an hourglass."

    Ask: Which system's hourglass? The same name carries different definitions.

  2. "The calculator says I am a pear."

    Ask: What did it input — shoulder width or bust? Different inputs produce different conclusions.

  3. "FFIT has nine shapes; why only five here?"

    Ask: Do the two share the same purpose and inputs? A research system is not the consumer labels.

  4. "Does the national standard classify me this way too?"

    Ask: Is it a size code or a styling label? Y/A/B/C are not apple/pear.

  5. "Which one is most accurate?"

    Ask: First ask what it is for. Different purposes cannot be ranked by accuracy alone.

11 / Method

Method and limitations

Method

This is a targeted comparison, not a systematic review. Sources were separated into apparel standards, measurement definitions, research systems, consumer and pattern guidance, and Bodytype's own rules. Each source is used only for the level of claim it can support, and all links were checked on 17 November 2026.

Limitations

  • FFIT Part I was read as abstract plus first-page full text; Part II was read in full. BSAS was read as the published abstract only — the SAGE full text was blocked — so its four-shape enumeration is corroborated by FFIT Part II's description of the related Auburn work, not by the full BSAS scale text.
  • GB/T 1335.2 Y/A/B/C ranges come from a mirror of the standard text, cross-checked with the official record; formal citation should use the official text. ISO 8559-1 and GB/T 16160 clause-level wording was not itemized.
  • The 2021 “up to 40%” figure is specific to FFIT versus SizeUK measurement-placement interpretations in 1,679 3D scans. It is not an error rate for all calculators or for Bodytype.
  • Consumer guides change; recheck the links before treating a specific wording as current. This guide contains no population study and cannot rank systems by accuracy.

12 / Sources

Sources

  1. GB/T 1335.2-2008 official recordSource

    国家标准全文公开系统, GB/T 1335.2-2008 服装号型 女子 (Standard sizing systems for garments - Women).

    Use: Standard number, title, current status, publication and implementation dates.

    Status: Official record reviewed 17 Nov 2026: current; published 2008-12-31, implemented 2009-08-01.

  2. GB/T 16160-2017 official recordSource

    国家标准信息公共服务平台, GB/T 16160-2017 服装用人体测量的尺寸定义与方法 (Anthropometric definitions and methods for garment).

    Use: Title, current status, dates and 2025 review conclusion.

    Status: Official record reviewed 17 Nov 2026: current; 2025 review concluded revision; plan 20252806-T-608 being approved.

  3. ISO 8559-1:2017Source

    ISO 8559-1:2017, Size designation of clothes — Part 1: Anthropometric definitions for body measurement. Edition 1, 2017-03.

    Use: Scope of the measurement-definition standard.

    Status: Official scope page reviewed 17 Nov 2026; confirmed current in 2026; clauses not itemized.

  4. The Concept Wardrobe — Determine Your Body Shape(s)Source

    The Concept Wardrobe, Determine Your Body Shape(s).

    Use: Five labels, four measured areas, three methods, 5%/25% editorial thresholds.

    Status: Page reviewed 17 Nov 2026.

  5. Who What Wear UK — What Body Shape Am I?Source

    Who What Wear UK, What Body Shape Am I? (Bradley Bayou technique).

    Use: Four labels, interchangeable shoulder/bust input, 5%/25% editorial thresholds.

    Status: Page reviewed 17 Nov 2026.

  6. Vogue China — pleated skirt body termsSource

    Vogue 中国, 人手一条的百褶裙 这样穿时髦又显瘦 (apple/banana/pear/hourglass).

    Use: Chinese consumer content using apple, banana, pear and hourglass.

    Status: Page reviewed 17 Nov 2026; circa 2017–2018 article.

  7. FFIT for Apparel Part ISource

    Simmons, K., Istook, C. L., & Devarajan, P. (2004). Female Figure Identification Technique (FFIT) for Apparel Part I: Describing Female Shapes. JTATM, 4(1).

    Use: FFIT background and the 3D-scan shape-sorting framework.

    Status: Abstract and first-page full text reviewed 17 Nov 2026; refereed.

  8. Parker et al. (2021) — FFIT reliabilitySource

    Parker, C. J., Hayes, S. G., Brownbridge, K., & Gill, S. (2021). Assessing the female figure identification technique's reliability as a body shape classification system. Ergonomics, 64(8), 1035–1051. DOI 10.1080/00140139.2021.1902572.

    Use: 1,679 3D scans; measurement-placement interpretation changes shape in up to 40% of cases; FFIT omits shoulders.

    Status: Abstract reviewed 17 Nov 2026.

  9. Bodytype rule library (algorithm v2)Read

    Bodytype, 体型分类规则与内容库(算法 v2); lib/body-type/rules.ts and thresholds.ts.

    Use: Site inputs, ratios, thresholds, rule order and boundaries.

    Status: Verified against source code 17 Nov 2026.

  10. GB/T 1335.2-2008 text mirrorSource

    GB/T 1335.2-2008 服装号型 女子, standard text mirror, clause 3.3.

    Use: Y/A/B/C codes and the bust-waist difference ranges.

    Status: Mirror clause 3.3 read 17 Nov 2026; cross-checked with the S1 official record. Formal citation should use the official text.

  11. WHO waist circumference and waist-hip ratioSource

    World Health Organization (2011). Waist circumference and waist-hip ratio: report of a WHO expert consultation, Geneva, 8–11 December 2008. ISBN 9789241501491.

    Use: Health-risk research boundary; not used in the algorithm.

    Status: Publication page reviewed 17 Nov 2026.

  12. The Concept Wardrobe — Kibbe introductionSource

    The Concept Wardrobe, An Introduction to the Kibbe Body Types; David Kibbe, Metamorphosis (1987).

    Use: Kibbe/Image Identity as a style system, not a proportion calculator.

    Status: Page reviewed 17 Nov 2026.

  13. University of Kentucky — How Do You See Your Body?Source

    University of Kentucky Cooperative Extension (2011). How Do You See Your Body? FCS2-846.

    Use: The within-1-inch straight rule; apple/reverse triangle grouping.

    Status: PDF reviewed 17 Nov 2026; issued 6-2011.

  14. FFIT for Apparel Part IISource

    Devarajan, P., & Istook, C. L. (2004). Validation of 'Female Figure Identification Technique (FFIT) for Apparel' Software. JTATM, 4(1).

    Use: Six girth inputs from 3D scans, nine shapes, software validation; describes the related Auburn four-shape work.

    Status: Full text (23 pages) reviewed 17 Nov 2026; refereed.

  15. Connell et al. (2006) — BSASSource

    Connell, L. J., Ulrich, P. V., Brannon, E. L., Alexander, M., & Presley, A. B. (2006). Body Shape Assessment Scale: Instrument Development for Analyzing Female Figures. Clothing and Textiles Research Journal, 24(2), 80–95. DOI 10.1177/0887302X0602400203.

    Use: BSAS nine-scale structure, expert assessment, scan samples.

    Status: Abstract reviewed via CrossRef 17 Nov 2026; SAGE full text blocked by Cloudflare. Four-shape enumeration corroborated by S15, not the BSAS full scale text.

  16. Sewing.org — Shapes, Sizes, and What to WearSource

    Sewing.org (2005). Shapes, Sizes, and What to Wear to Look Great. Guideline 10.105.

    Use: Five labels (two rectangles, no apple) and the mirror-silhouette method.

    Status: PDF reviewed 17 Nov 2026; dated 9/05.

Last updated 17 November 2026. The date changes only when the content is revised, not when the site is deployed.

Cite this page

A stable reference for the comparison

Bodytype.org. (2026). Same names, different systems: body shape classification for a body type calculator. https://bodytype.org/guides/body-shape-classification-systems

Page URLDownload the data